If you own a business in Florida and have employees, workers' compensation insurance may be a legal requirement. But what about employer's liability insurance? Do you need both, and what's the difference?
These coverages are usually sold together on the same policy, but they protect against different risks. Workers' compensation provides benefits to employees who have qualifying work-related injuries or illnesses. Employer's liability insurance helps protect the business against certain legal claims arising from those injuries.
Understanding how they work together can help Florida business owners avoid confusion about what their insurance actually covers.
What is workers' compensation insurance?
Workers' compensation provides medical and financial benefits to employees who suffer qualifying injuries or illnesses arising from their employment.
For example, suppose an employee at a Sarasota restaurant slips on a wet kitchen floor and breaks their wrist. If the injury qualifies, the employee may receive medical treatment and wage-replacement benefits while recovering.
According to the Florida Department of Financial Services, workers' compensation benefits can include:[1]
- Medical treatment: authorized doctor's visits, hospitalization, physical therapy, prescriptions, and other medically necessary treatment.
- Temporary disability benefits: partial wage replacement when an employee can't work or has qualifying reduced earnings.
- Permanent disability benefits: compensation for eligible workers with lasting impairments or qualifying permanent total disabilities.
- Death benefits: financial assistance for eligible dependents when a work-related injury or illness results in death.
How much does Florida workers' comp pay?
Florida sets specific rules for calculating disability benefits:
- For temporary total disability, eligible employees generally receive 66⅔% of their regular wages, subject to Florida's maximum weekly compensation rate.
- Temporary disability benefits are generally subject to a combined maximum of 104 weeks, with some additional restrictions and exceptions.
- For qualifying workplace fatalities, Florida provides death benefits of up to $150,000, including funeral expenses of up to $7,500.
These amounts are set by Florida's workers' compensation system. They aren't negotiated between the employer and the employee.[1]
What is employer's liability insurance?
Employer's liability insurance helps protect a business against certain legal liabilities resulting from an employee's work-related bodily injury or occupational disease. It's commonly included as Part Two of a standard workers' compensation and employers' liability policy.
The distinction matters:
- Workers' compensation pays the benefits required by workers' compensation law.
- Employer's liability addresses certain damages the business may legally owe outside those statutory benefits, subject to the policy's conditions, exclusions, and limits. Depending on the circumstances and the policy language, that can include legal defense costs, settlements, or court judgments.
Employer's liability does not cover every lawsuit involving an injured employee. Florida law substantially limits when an employee or anyone else can sue an employer over a workplace injury, and those limits directly affect when employer's liability coverage might apply.
Employer's liability vs. workers' comp: key differences
| Workers' compensation | Employer's liability | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Provides statutory benefits for qualifying work injuries | Protects against certain covered legal liabilities |
| Primary beneficiary | Injured employee or eligible dependents | Insured business |
| Common expenses | Medical treatment, wage replacement, disability benefits | Covered damages and legal defense |
| Employer negligence must be proven? | Generally no | A legally valid liability claim is required |
| Coverage limits | Benefits set by applicable law | Policy-specific dollar limits |
| Standard policy location | Part One | Part Two |
The two coverages complement each other, but neither one is unlimited protection.
Can an employee sue their employer in Florida?
Generally, Florida's workers' compensation system limits an injured employee's ability to sue their employer for a covered workplace injury. This is known as the exclusive remedy rule. Under Florida Statute 440.11, workers' compensation liability generally replaces other civil liability arising from qualifying workplace injuries.[2]
The law does provide limited exceptions.
When workers' comp immunity may not apply
- Failure to secure required coverage. If an employer fails to secure the workers' compensation required by Florida law, an injured employee may be able to file a civil lawsuit instead of claiming statutory benefits.
- Certain intentional misconduct. Florida law also recognizes an exception for an employer's intentional tort. The standard is demanding. Among other things, the employee may need to show that the employer deliberately intended to injure them, or knowingly engaged in conduct virtually certain to cause injury while concealing or misrepresenting the danger. Ordinary negligence doesn't meet this standard.
An exception that allows a lawsuit does not automatically mean the employer's liability policy will pay the claim.
What types of claims can employer's liability address?
Standard employer's liability policies contemplate several categories of injury-related liability. Whether those claims can actually proceed against an employer in Florida is a separate legal question.
Third-party-over claims
A third-party-over claim happens when another party involved in an employee's injury tries to hold the employer responsible. For instance, an injured employee might bring a product liability claim against an equipment manufacturer, and the manufacturer might then try to shift some of the responsibility to the employer.
Although this type of claim is recognized in insurance terminology, Florida's exclusive remedy law generally protects qualifying employers from third-party claims arising from employee injuries. Employer's liability coverage shouldn't be assumed to apply.
Claims involving family members
Some standard employer's liability provisions address claims involving bodily injury to an employee's family members, or loss of services resulting from an employee's injury. Florida's exclusive remedy law generally restricts these claims against a protected employer as well. Whether a legal remedy and insurance coverage exist depends on the facts, the applicable law, and the policy terms.
Dual-capacity claims
A dual-capacity claim alleges that the employer is responsible for an injury in some capacity separate from its role as employer. Florida recognizes only narrow circumstances in which a separate legal capacity may affect workers' compensation immunity. Manufacturing equipment, owning property, or performing another business function does not by itself eliminate an employer's immunity.
These examples show why employers should understand both Florida's legal restrictions and the actual language of their policies.
A Florida Supreme Court case shows why policy language matters
In Morales v. Zenith Insurance Co., decided by the Florida Supreme Court on December 4, 2014, an employee of a landscaping business died following a workplace accident.[3]
The employee's estate obtained a $9.525 million wrongful-death judgment against the employer and tried to recover it under the employer's liability portion of the company's policy. The Court determined that the policy's workers' compensation exclusion, together with a settlement release, prevented the estate from collecting that judgment from the insurer.
The takeaway for business owners: having an employer's liability policy does not guarantee coverage for every lawsuit or judgment arising from a workplace injury. Coverage depends on the applicable law and the terms of the insurance contract.
Who needs workers' compensation insurance in Florida?
Florida's requirements depend on your industry, number of employees, and business structure. The Department of Financial Services sets different general thresholds for construction, non-construction, and agricultural employers.[4]
Non-construction businesses: four or more employees
Most non-construction businesses must carry workers' compensation once they have four or more employees. That includes retail stores, restaurants, professional offices, service companies, and other non-construction employers. Full-time and part-time employees generally count toward the threshold. Owner status and qualifying exemptions can affect the count.
Construction businesses: one or more employees
Florida generally requires construction businesses to carry workers' compensation with one or more employees, subject to applicable owner exemptions. This affects roofing companies, electrical contractors, plumbing businesses, and other companies classified as construction.
Contractors also have specific responsibilities for their subcontractors' coverage. Under Florida's rules, a contractor may become responsible for workers' compensation benefits when a subcontractor fails to maintain required coverage.
Agricultural businesses
Agricultural employers generally must carry workers' compensation when they have:
- Six or more regular employees; or
- Twelve or more qualifying seasonal employees who meet the employment-duration requirements. DFS guidance describes seasonal thresholds involving more than 30 days during a season or more than 45 days in a calendar year.
Are business owners exempt?
Some qualifying corporate officers and LLC members may apply for an exemption. Exemptions have specific eligibility and application requirements, and an exemption for an owner does not exempt the company's other employees from coverage requirements.
Is employer's liability insurance required in Florida?
Florida law requires employers to secure workers' compensation benefits. Employer's liability is generally packaged with a standard workers' compensation policy rather than imposed as a separate, universal purchase requirement. A typical policy includes:
- Part One: Workers' Compensation Insurance. Pays the benefits required under applicable workers' compensation laws.
- Part Two: Employers' Liability Insurance. Covers certain legal liabilities resulting from work-related bodily injuries or occupational diseases, subject to the policy's limits and exclusions.
Check your declarations page to confirm both parts are included and to see the limits.
Is employer's liability the same as EPLI?
No. Employer's liability and employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) cover different risks. Employer's liability concerns certain legal claims arising from workplace bodily injury or occupational disease. EPLI generally concerns covered claims about employment-related conduct, such as:
- Wrongful termination
- Employment discrimination
- Sexual harassment
- Retaliation
- Other covered employment practices
An employee who hurts their back moving merchandise would generally have a workers' compensation claim. An employee alleging they were fired because of discrimination might have a claim involving EPLI. One doesn't replace the other.
Does general liability cover injured employees?
Commercial general liability insurance primarily addresses third-party bodily injury, property damage, and related liability claims. It generally excludes bodily injury to employees arising out of their employment.
Picture two incidents at a Sarasota retail store:
- Customer injury: a customer slips on a wet floor and is hurt. The store's general liability policy may respond if the claim meets the policy's terms.
- Employee injury: an employee slips on the same wet floor while working. Workers' compensation would generally be the coverage that applies.
A general liability policy is not a substitute for workers' compensation when workers' compensation is required.
Five things Florida business owners should review
- Employee count and industry classification. Confirm whether your business meets Florida's requirements. Construction and non-construction businesses have different thresholds.
- Employer's liability coverage. Check that your workers' compensation policy includes Part Two.
- Policy limits. Review your employer's liability limits for bodily injury by accident and by disease. They're separate from statutory workers' compensation benefits.
- Subcontractor relationships. If you hire subcontractors, confirm your responsibilities under Florida workers' compensation law.
- Other employee-related risks. Consider whether EPLI, a commercial umbrella, or other coverages fit the risks workers' comp and employer's liability don't address.
The short version
Workers' compensation pays benefits for qualifying workplace injuries and illnesses. Employer's liability protects the business against certain covered legal liabilities that can arise from those injuries. Knowing what Florida requires is only part of the picture. It also matters what your current policy includes, what its limits are, and where its exclusions apply.
Have questions about your business insurance?
Lamb Insurance Agency helps Sarasota-area retail stores, restaurants, professional offices and other local businesses compare commercial insurance in Sarasota and review the coverage they already have. Call or text (941) 225-2335, or send us your current declarations page.
Get a Business Insurance Quote →Sources
- Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Workers' Compensation, Benefits Available to Injured Workers.
- Florida Statutes § 440.11, Exclusiveness of liability. The Florida Legislature.
- Morales v. Zenith Insurance Co., Florida Supreme Court, decided December 4, 2014.
- Florida Department of Financial Services, Division of Workers' Compensation, Workers' Compensation Coverage Requirements.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and it is not a statement of what any particular policy covers. Coverage depends on your policy's terms, conditions and exclusions. Statutes, benefit amounts and coverage thresholds change, so confirm current requirements with the Florida Division of Workers' Compensation or a licensed Florida professional.
Frequently Asked Questions
It depends on the business. Most non-construction employers generally need coverage at four or more employees, while construction employers generally need coverage with one or more employees, subject to applicable exemptions. Agricultural employers have their own thresholds.
It is commonly included as Part Two of a standard workers' compensation policy. However, business owners should verify their policy declarations, limits, and exclusions.
Florida's exclusive remedy law generally limits these lawsuits when workers' compensation applies. Certain exceptions exist, including an employer's failure to secure required coverage and qualifying intentional torts.
No, not ordinarily. Wrongful termination claims generally fall within employment practices liability insurance (EPLI) rather than employer's liability bodily-injury coverage.
Yes. Employer's liability coverage has specific monetary limits, usually listed separately for bodily injury by accident and bodily injury by disease. Workers' compensation benefits, by contrast, are determined by applicable law.
Yes. A business that does not meet a mandatory coverage threshold may still seek workers' compensation insurance, subject to insurer requirements and eligibility.
